Order of operations in Hard and Expert equations
Easy and Medium use equations with two numbers and an answer, like 17 + 8 = 25. Hard and Expert also include longer equations with three numbers and two different operators, such as 3 + 4 × 2 = 11. For these, the order matters, and the rules are the ones from school arithmetic.
The rules the puzzles use
- Multiplication and division happen before addition and subtraction.
- When two operations are of the same kind, they run left to right.
- Every step has to be a positive whole number, including the middle steps, and the final answer.
The last two use operations of the same kind, so they run left to right. Doing 6 × 5 first in the fourth line would give 18 ÷ 30, which is not even a whole number. That is a quick way to see that left to right is the only reading that works.
Why some equations never appear
The generator rejects any equation where a middle step would be negative or fractional. 98 − 55 × 2 is rejected, because 55 × 2 is 110 and 98 − 110 is below zero. 7 ÷ 2 + 5 is rejected because 7 ÷ 2 is not a whole number. When you see a longer equation in a puzzle, you can trust that every step of it works out cleanly, and use that to narrow the candidates.
Solving one blank in a longer equation
Work in the reverse of the order the equation is calculated. Take away the addition or subtraction first, then undo the multiplication or division.
In each case the last operation in the order is the first to be undone. If a tile gives a middle step that is negative or not a whole number, it cannot be the answer.
When there are two blanks
Use the positive-step rule as a filter. In A − B × C = D, the product B × C has to be less than A, so a large tile in the B or C cell is only possible when A is larger still. In A ÷ B + C = D, the division has to be exact, so A has to be a multiple of B. These two facts alone usually cut the candidates down to a few, and the crossing equations finish the job.
Common mistakes
- Reading left to right every time. 3 + 4 × 2 is 11, not 14.
- Forgetting that division must be exact. 12 ÷ 4 can appear and 12 ÷ 5 cannot.
- Checking only the final answer. A tile that gives the right total through a negative middle step is not allowed.